On Guy Rundle’s SMS

To our Subscribers and Supporters, a Note from the Arena Publications Editors

The Arena Publications Editors were dismayed at the contents of a text sent by one of our editors, Guy Rundle, to RN’s Breakfast Show host Patricia Karvelas on Thursday 18 October. It could be taken to suggest that some forms of unwanted sexual attention or unwanted touching were not a form of sexual assault. The use of the word ‘groping’ moreover carried the connotation of something merely incidental and potentially excusable. That word does not carry what to our minds is the crucial dimension of power that typically operates across sexual relationships between women and men, and which is constituted in deep, ongoing structures of sexism and misogyny, which fundamentally shape aspects of our culture. Guy’s largely hidden point in the text was that definitions of assault have changed significantly in recent times, and that this must be taken into account when seeking explanations of any rise in sexual violence. This is an important point, and from our point of view potentially opens onto significant questions around emerging sexual mores and new structures of power around sexual life and identity. We intend to produce a special theme in the pages of Arena Quarterly over time on the questions raised in this statement, which follows many considered contributions already made on these issues in our pages, including by Guy.

The Arena Editors have met with Guy and as well as our statement here, we have invited him to make a brief statement, which appears below. We have asked Guy to step aside from the co-editorship of Arena Quarterly for a period as further discussions occur.

Statement by Guy Rundle

In mid-October I sent a text to the Radio National Breakfast Program on the line they advertise for texts. I responded to an interview with Angela Lynch, Executive Officer at the Queensland Sexual Assault Network, concerning a measured rise in the occurrence of sexual assault. 

The text stated: ‘it’s because every grope is now a sexual assault’. 

This was taken as expressing the idea that ‘unwanted sexual touching’ as not sexual assault and was ‘falsely inflating’ the statistics. This is not what I believe. All unwanted sexual touching is sexual assault. 

My intent was to argue that unwanted sexual touching has only recently been classified as sexual assault, from the 2000s onwards, in both the law and criminology. This shift may be part of the rise in reporting of sexual assault.

The term ‘grope’ was wrongly chosen. Seeking to use a term from everyday life, I did not consider how trivialising, insensitive and vulgar the term was, and the false impression it would give of flippancy about this issue. 

I regret any damage done to Arena, by my texting into the show, and I apologise for creating an entirely false impression that sexual assault is a trivial matter.

Guy Rundle

About the author

Arena Publications Editors

The people that make up the Arena Publication Editors can be found via this link.

More articles by Arena Publications Editors

Categorised: Arena Online

15 Comments

Support Arena

Independent publications and critical thought are more important than ever. Arena has never relied on or received government funding. It has sustained its activities largely through the voluntary work and funding provided by editors and supporters. If Arena is to continue and to expand its readership, we need your support to do it.

Comments

I would never trivialise sexual assault says Guy “Brittany Higgins had about as much motive as anyone has ever had to make a false sex crime claim” Rundle.

Really? What a joke to present his statement here.

Arena is as nuts as Crikey. Rundle’s text was clumsy but he was way, way closer to the truth than Karvelas, whose extended interview was chummy bullshit.

I’m not impressed or enlightened by ARENA’s comment re Rundle’s deployment of ‘grope’ in what he wrote to Karvelas. Rundle himself, and very unbelievably in my view, says his use of the term in the context of his remarks, gave the ‘false impression’..’of flippancy about this issue’. I don’t think that any impression of flippancy on Rundle’s part in this instance is at all ‘false’. In fact, it is about the only reasonable conclusion which can be drawn from what he wrote. And how did an experienced essayist, polemicist, analyst, theoretician and culture-jamming savoir-faire doyen, word-smith extraordinaire, gonzo-transcending, and zappy verbal pyrotechnical maître de such as Rundle not find it within himself to even ‘consider how trivialising, insensitive and vulgar the term was’?? And what word does ARENA believe would ‘carry’ to its (plural) ‘minds’, ‘the crucial dimension of power that typically operates across sexual relationships between women and men’ and which could perhaps have been illuminated and contextualised Guy’s ostensibly ‘hidden point’, a point which he lacked the perspicacity to clearly put forward? Well ARENA is silent on what the word might be, but it knows well enough that ‘groping’ is not it. But at least ARENA can discern what is ‘hidden’ here and knows enough to distance itself for now from the discomfort caused by what wasn’t ‘hidden’.

How enlightening that once again the debate on how we discuss the sexual assault of women is being largely driven by men. Let me say – quite controversially – that groping IS trivial in the face of rape.

As a woman who has experienced both, I am deeply offended and traumatised when people demand that groping be categorised under the same offence category as rape. But the point that Guy Rundle was trying to make – and which I immediately understood him to be making – is that when we discuss the statistics of offending (any type of offence) and state that its rising, the fact that the definition of what gets included in that offence category is entirely relevant when it has caused an increase in reporting. When people (Karvelas and her guest) do not include this in their discussion, its being dishonest. They were trying to push a point about women’s safety and doing so in a false and disingenuous way.

I absolutely agree and support Guy Rundle’s commentary, albeit being done a bit clumsily. Its clear to me that the majority of negative reponse is either virtue-signalling or politically motivated.

For the first, I’m angry that so many people are taking offence on behalf of sexual assault victims without actually being in that cohort themselves. Shut up, ok?

For the second, its curious to me that no-one has drawn the link between Guy Rundles’ two pieces on the demise of quality radio on RN, singling out Karvelas as lacklustre, and another on the culture of the ABC “where the cultural producer elite are largely making content… Every series or program becomes a chance to proselytise diversity … by historically inaccurate or one-dimensional heroic, sort of diversity Stalinist, narratives.”

This clutching of pearls smells very much like revenge for speaking out. I am a sexual assault survivor and I stand in support of Guy Rundle.

Well said Jane, this is the kind of identity wars outrage that calls for censorship and destruction of the individual. AIHW (Aust Institute of Health and Welfare) reports that the rate of intimate partner homicide decreased from 0.66 per 100,000 people in 1989–90 to 0.18 per 100,000 people in 2022–23. This is a dramatic achievement and should be celebrated as such, sure it would be good to reduce it further but the breast beating about a sudden crisis is absurd. It would be very unlikely to expect that sexual assault had dramatically increased when death by DV has reduced by such a large amount. Rundle’s remark was dead right and needed no apology other than to explain to those that were offended exactly what he meant. Of course Rundle isn’t the first to have his livelihood threatened for making a sensible contribution to an important debate. I was one of many long term Crikey subscribers who have cancelled their subscription for what is an appalling affront to freedom of debate.

The most bemusing thing about both this note from the Arena Publications Editors and Arena co-founder Guy Rundle’s accompanying statement is the performative redundance of both. Who, exactly, do you all think you are writing the words above for, and what, exactly, do you think they will achieve?

Arena is a subscription publication for the exploration of ideas, read – I am confident enough to at least assert – almost exclusively by engaged, intelligent and supremely well-educated Australians with a ferocious appetite for and a well-honed capacity to manage for ourselves whatever the hell nuanced, challenging and even outright offensive ones human beings can conceive and put into words, without needing our hands held, our sensitivies coddled or our bottoms wiped. No-one here is unfamiliar with Rundle’s thinking or his writing, including on this subject. None of us who grasped instantly the substantive purpose and sound intent of this now ludicrously over-amplified text – which he has here laboriously and (one suspects, one certainly hopes) dutifully deconstructed for us in unnecessary detail, like a kindergarten teacher spelling out ‘the sky is blue, kids, and mummies are good’ in magnetic lettering – needed or wanted any such explication. (I for one would have far preferred the Arena editors to have the decency to simply write: ‘We think you are stupid, fragile and childish, poor dear Jack’.) As for those who profess to have been outraged by what he sent to RN – again, I would assert (certainly of the readership here) in a largely performative way – well, one is sorry to make even bigger fools of you than you have yourselves, but nothing you could possibly construct in mitigation, for that part of your readership, will do anything but amplify their pantomime outrage-now-becoming-sorrowful-anger still further. By all means publish an entire edition bespoke-crafted to un-send Rundle’s text. (There is indeed much to talk about – properly – in these ‘gender war’ areas.) But you won’t ever succeed in satisfying those who chose to be outraged by it. Seeking to broach contrived intellectual gaps the very maintenance of which are the entire point of them in the first place is heroic in its witlessness. All this exercise in public editorial hand-wringing achieves thus far is to ossify usefully intersecting enquiry into these issues yet more. So best you make any special edition it does spawn the best ever; you’ve made the stakes exceptionally high. Good – genuinely – luck with it.

Because – perhaps Arena hasn’t noticed? – the civilised world is navigating a profound epistemic crisis just now. A confluence of disorienting technological disruptions, long-accumulated cultural fragmentation, a loss of intellectual self-confidence among the educated elite – you, our would-be brilliant, soaring best angels – and the commensurate regressive resurgence of always-lurking base human instincts are combining to savage any functioning connection between the human abstract and the human material. That fundamental existential crisis – in what we humans know, and can know, and choose as a matter of necessity to agree we know, and how we communicate (including, yes, debate and negotiate and advance) those known things to and with each other, for collective material effect – is underpinning and fuelling every other existential crisis we simultaneously face, from global heating to geopolitical brinkmanship to economic unsustainability to the election of those who would steward us safely, or not, through them. As ever, but in this crisis moment even more critically than usual, the core epistemic responsibility of public intellectuals generally, and especially those in our elite universities who we as a society expressly employ for the purpose, is to safeguard the functioning link between the abstract ideas we human beings can have, the language in which we express them, and the material world in which we all of us live. The first and primary job of publications like Arena is to resist adding more lies to a public polity now drowning in a tsunami of them. Lies of mere material fact are so easily dealt with as to be near-irrelevant to the real nature of the crisis (Lumpen grifters like Trump do truth a great and solidifying favour with every uttered empirically-manifest absurdity.) The heavy lifting you public intellectuals really need to start doing again is with the lighter loads, leadenly freighted as they are with subjectivity, interpretive choice, agency optionality. You’ve despatched God, which is no bad thing, but that makes you – whether you like it or not – our next best epistemic buck-stopper. So: you can all choose to be ‘outraged’ by Rundle’s text, sure you can. Or you can choose to find something more useful, more civilised and civilising, in it. Arraigned against the latter act of godly intellectual will are…all the usual individually-regressive intellectual suspects: shabby personal point-scoring, orthodox prudence, pragmatic expedience, careerist opportunism…an ‘ironic’ and self-exculpating quarantining of your own inner uncommon sense of truth, especially. But the choice is, collectively, solely the Academy’s. You intellectuals; you daft, self-gaslighting professional thinkers: you have let us down in moments of crisis too often this last hundred years or so already. Don’t do it again. The entire f**king planet is on fire this time, and we are all going to die, unless you start telling us the truth again.

On matters big and trivial alike. It’s a habit. You all need to exercise it again. Often, it hurts. It must needs hurt in the abstract the most when we’re hurting the most in the material.

The useful and responsible public intellectual response, then, to the highly un-useful and irresponsible (marginally, as with all teacup storms) wider response to Rundle’s trivial text…is to stand your bloody epistemic ground, in the fullest sense of how we humans steward human knowledge. Demand that we – being not privileged like you (as most of us are not) to be paid to protect the meaningful connection of human ideas, words and material actions – work as hard as you (and Rundle) have done to explain it, now – but for ourselves instea. Demand of us that we ‘get it’ – for ourselves. Expect of us that we recognise the points he was making – for ourselves. Without needing to be so instructed. Insist that much, of us. Here of all places, at this publication: demand that we think again for ourselves, fully, which is to say to concede (for ourselves) all the nuance and context which you (and Rundle) have somehow felt it ‘necessary’ to do on our behalf.

Expecting, demanding that, of us, is the sole point of you. That is your vocation: to civilise us, thence for us all to better civilise the world.

You need to get that epistemic self-confidence back, the gentle and inclusive hard-willed arrogance of intellectual leadership. We’re not bloody children. You demean us and your own vocation by treating us as if we are. You are also blinkered cretins, apparently far too squirreled up your own backsides to see the world clearly, as it is: what is especially galling in this miserably trivial case – what is especially obtuse of you lot more generally, just now – is that the vast majority of us who aren’t as over-educated into stupidity as too many of you seem to be do or would understand perfectly well, instinctively and un-vexed, the driving point of that text. Even its language, which the kinder of you contrive to call ‘clumsy’, or some such, is unremarkable. We all of us have conversations, on these subjects, in this kind of language, every day – and I just bet including all of you, the ‘publicly outraged’, in private. (I’m right, aren’t I, Arena Publications Editors.) This artificial and unnecessary epistemic cleaving – of you (our very best thinkers) in your public abstract, from the rest of us (including you) in each our private abstract, which in turn are what remains truly connected to the way we all live our material lives, individual and colelctive – is the most catastrophic epistemic blunder we can go on making just now. The only place anyone has been ‘outraged’ – pretended to be so – by what Rundle wrote is…in the public Town Square. Such conspicuous and performative ‘abstract moralising’ from privileged public intellectuals has always intensified in times of spiralling material world brutality, cruelty and exclusion, and usually, of course, as frantically guilt-drenched precursor to nihilistic catharsis. On insanely trivial failures of thought, such as this one, ruinous bloodlettings feed and grow.

So let’s not help grow another one, Arena. How about let’s not go down that bloody path, this time. Let’s all of us stop lying publicly to each other. There’s a lot of very difficult, but very true things, that desperately need to be said, out loud but without excluding any of us. Few thinkers and writers around nowadays are as good at doing so as this publication. And its co-founder especially.

Don’t kneecap yourselves, wholly-unnecessarily. That will be for our public intellectuals to fail us, yet again. Best regards.

Thank you, Jack. Well said.

We all have to better than this. We all have to be tougher than this. The world is on fire. There is too much to do to spend precious moment on misplaced navel gazing.

Toughen up, Arena.

How to navigate a path through the chaos of contemporary sexual politics? Arena editors are at a loss, and Guy Rundle’s “slip of the tongue” hasn’t helped. But rather than obfuscating the event as the recent Arena editorial seeks to do, bizarrely referring to “hidden” meanings in Guy’s recent eruption, what if we take his “mistake”, his “misspeaking”, very seriously, allowing that signifier “groping” its effects? Because so many men really are groping—they are groping with their own sexuality, their own longings, and they are baffled by the clumsiness of their encounters with women. Guy Rundle himself gives an account of his own ineffectual longings for beautiful young women in his recent memoir of Melbourne in the 1980s (see Meanjin).

To believe that innocent men are caught by wicked women in a web of false claims of sexual assault is a displacement of these anxieties. We know the statistics on the incidence of false claims, we know the statistics on sexual violence against women and children, we know the experience of women who attempt to bring their cases through the criminal justice system, but all the same we will believe that the important issue is women falsely claiming sexual assault?

That Arena editors think they are suitably placed to curate a special issue devoted to a consideration of emerging sexual mores is laughable. In 1992, Guy Rundle, Alison Caddick, Paul James and I were given the rich opportunity to found the new Arena magazine, with the task of engaging a new readership in the politics of the day, including of course sexual politics. I resigned over the editors’ choice to publish in the very first issue an article that insisted that female academics were resentful, they could never be satisfied: however much they were given, they wanted more! The particular word that was used to describe these unhappy female academics’ state of mind was ressentiment, as if using the French word would lend some subtlety and nuance to the argument. Not much has changed since then—resentment doesn’t mean resentment, and groping doesn’t really mean groping at all.

kimmo! hail comrade. yes, even the lefty intellectuals have got the vapours. the poor dears.

but the revolution lives on, sister.

It was a clumsy and foolish use of the word “grope” in the course of making the point that the definition of sexual assault has expanded during the past twenty years. Guy Rundle was observing this definitional change must be considered when interpreting long-term trends in the prevalence of this form of sex crime. Why should someone be banned from public discourse because they make an ill-considered word choice in an off the cuff SMS message? Crikey’s decision to stop publishing Guy Rundle’s articles was an instance of performative virtue devoid of substance. Guy Rundle has proven himself as a perceptive and erudite writer over a period of decades. A simple apology and a vow to do better is the appropriate remedy here, not depriving Crikey subscribers of Guy Rundle’s excellent articles. Crikey’s decision is symptomatic of a preference for performative virtue over true virtue, and a preference for kneejerk reactions over nuanced discussion. Nobody is made any safer from sexual assault by the virtue-signalling cowardice of Crikey. They chose to bow to the mob-like mentality that so often characterises elite discussions of these topics. Regular people are far more practical and sensible, and far more focused on remediating the actual problem. Cultural elites tend to think that harsh policing of people’s words is a substitute for genuine social change. It is not. I wish they would understand that reality.

Comments closed