Anitra Nelson, ed., Routledge Handbook of Degrowth, Routledge, 2025.
This comprehensive collection introduces the degrowth movement as a plurality of perspectives with a common purpose. The collection elaborates how degrowth aims to satisfy basic needs through a light ecological footprint. Collective sufficiency is animated by direct democracy. Caring for people and the earth are its focus.
As Eric Pineault writes in one of the introductory chapters, degrowth is a response to the current ecological crisis supercharged by capitalism. Capitalist accumulation has come to depend on mass overconsumption, validating mass overproduction. In this context, a common view deferring degrowth is that the Global South needs to grow its way out of poverty. However, as Timothée Parrique shows, capitalist growth benefits the world’s rich at the expense of the Global South. The need to reduce energy and resource use applies primarily to the globally affluent, not to those struggling to meet basic needs. Indeed, Ulrich Bland and Markus Wissen spell out the implications of the appropriation of labour and resources from the Global South. There is no way to move to a degrowth future without losses for those who have been the beneficiaries of these inequities. This is reinforced by other contributors who argue that a social metabolism that might fit with planetary boundaries is only possible outside of a capitalist economic system.

Origins and stepping stones
As the collection documents, the political history of the Left can be viewed from the perspective of degrowth. Debates arose in the late twentieth century. For example, André Gorz, a neo-Marxist theorist, doubted whether capitalism could do without growth. At the same time, the Romanian mathematician and economist Georgescu-Roegen argued that the laws of physics made endless growth an impossibility. This spilled over into different forms of degrowth politics across the world.
In Europe, one important moment was a French gathering in 2009. An Association of Objectors to Growth developed a platform for degrowth. For this association, degrowth is to be achieved ‘without taking power’ by ‘re-localising democratic control’. Its influential platform included re-localisation, instituting a maximum income, taxing use of resources, banning the car and nuclear industries, freeing access to basic goods and providing universal access to basic services.
In Latin America (as David Barkin describes), in Africa (the subject of Roland Ngam’s chapter) and elsewhere, Indigenous people and peasant movements inspire degrowth. The Zapatista rebellion is exemplary. In taking autonomous control of their lands in 1994, they promoted Indigenous communal relations. The political form associated with these Indigenous movements is participatory democracy rather than representative democracy, with surpluses allocated to purposes decided by the community.
Degrowth practices
A complex smorgasbord of chapters in the collection reveals some of the divisions within the movement. On the one hand, a set of recommendations on how democratically run states might operationalise degrowth: conversely, a celebration of prefigurative initiatives organised by grassroots activists—with no intention to cement degrowth as state policy.
From the statist side, Mladen Domazet’s chapter, for example, provides methods for decision-making bodies to set targets for action. Similarly, Eeva Houtbecker’s chapter on work promotes a statist version of degrowth—regulating for a four-day week, a job guarantee, workplace democracy, and a universal basic income. These strategies fit with proposals for a strongly regulated market economy to replace capitalism. By contrast, a chapter called ‘Re-Imagining Collaboration’ describes prefigurative grassroots interventions: bike sharing and repair, a community-supported farm and a rural degrowth commune. These projects align with the horizontalist approach.
The horizontalist approach is one of three different post-capitalist scenarios hosted within the degrowth movement. Horizontalists do not call upon the state to enact policies consistent with degrowth but begin to embody an alternative. Organisation is to be based in assemblies, with direct democracy and an attempt to reach consensus. In a non-monetary economic orientation, resources are shared and managed by the community. Producers and communities work out what they are going to make and how they are going to distribute it.
‘Commoning’ is often suggested as the most appropriate institutional vehicle for the horizontalist scenario, involving the development of collectively shared, community-managed resources. From the Brisbane Tool Library and peer-to-peer software networks that produce free programs and distribute them to a self-organised energy cooperative in Greece that runs solar power production for 60 households, ‘commoning’ is proposed as an alternative to market capitalism.
The second scenario is very familiar in the environmentalist movement. An early version of this is Herman Daly’s ‘steady state economy’. I think of it as the welfare state on steroids and call it ‘radical reformism’. The commanding heights (as they have been called) are controlled by the state. In this scenario, a state in a representative democracy regulates the economy to provide essential services, such as food, water, education and transport. In contrast, a large part of the rest of the economy remains, owned by private firms and cooperatives. A small informal sector operates as a non-market community sphere. Typical policies associated with this approach are universal basic income and tax reform.
The third scenario, also statist, is associated with democratic socialism—ownership of the means of production through a democratic state. Government departments organise democratic ecological planning and wage labour, while only a small sector of the economy remains in private hands or is run by cooperatives.
Gareth Dale’s chapter on eco-socialism illustrates these contending influences. He advocates public ownership along with participatory management of these cooperatives by their workers and communities. Dale contrasts this approach with that of liberal degrowthers, who advocate private property, markets and individualism, along with the three Rs of ‘reduce, re-use, recycle’. Here I am at a loss. I do not know of any degrowthers whose program could be summarised in that way. The people Dale seems to be talking about are known as ‘ecological modernisation’ advocates. Ecological modernisation has no problem with capitalism or markets. It relies on public pressure moving governments to encourage capitalism to be more ecological. Yet this has never been a degrowth viewpoint. Radical reformism is a more accurate reading of much of the degrowth movement. While radical reformism certainly advocates private property as part of the mix for ‘post-capitalism’, it also envisages public ownership of essential services and strong regulation rather than just a change in community sentiment.
When Jason Hickel wrote Less is More (2021), an influential text in the degrowth movement, he situated his suggestions squarely in the middle of the movement, with a version of radical reformism. More recently, without any change of heart, Hickel refers to his position as democratic socialist. These two positions provide a clear pathway—begin with radical reformism, then intensify the emphasis on public ownership. However, what gets left out is a critique of statist economies of any kind, whether capitalist, radical reformist or socialist.
Futures
The strength of the degrowth movement is clear, but it is also a victim of its growing recognition. While degrowth started out as a movement of activists and practitioners, one line of argument in the collection suggests that, as degrowth has been increasingly taken up by academics, the initiators have been sidelined. Activist projects are marginalised at degrowth conferences; the writings and presentations of academic experts bypass the public and most activists; and academic researchers become insulated from prefiguring initiatives. Key academic ‘stars’ of the degrowth movement now have huge profiles in academia. Their jobs allow and compel them to produce written material. If they write engaging prose, they inevitably start to define the movement.
However, the reality is that most non-academic participants in degrowth are tuning into social media sites, podcasts and YouTube videos. There is a host of content providers on these sites that are unknown to academic degrowth writers. But these influencers inform most of the theoretical understandings of degrowth movement participants at the grassroots. The supposed high status of academic stars of degrowth is something of an illusion when viewed from this perspective.
This must-have collection returns us to the grounded theory and practice of the degrowth movement. The collection must be congratulated for representing the different strands of the degrowth movement, giving us a sense of the lively debate that animates degrowth at the present time.